I don't see any need for special handling of AI assisted artwork submissions as far as "drowning out" other artwork goes. Any user who floods the site with multiple rapid submissions already has their submissions squelched from appearing on the front page temporarily.
If submissions of AI assisted art are "trivial" (anyone could use the AI to make the same thing in just a few minutes) then, again, those submissions are treated the same as other "trivial" submissions. Any time someone draws a crude stick figure of limited usefulness and uploads it, it gets evaluated for how much effort it is saving anyone and will be taken down if it's quicker to make your own than to download that guy's version.
However, keeping it clear which submissions are AI assisted is important, in my opinion. Beyond just tagging something as being AI-generated or AI assisted, there are very specific Terms of Use for the various tools out there. Not all of them are compatible with the open licenses we support. For that reason, I will insist upon any such submission including a link to the specific version of AI tool that was used so that everyone can be confident the allowed usage of output will not get anyone in trouble.
It would be nice to add the checkbox or some additional prompting in the submission process for this. I'm not sure how feasible that is under the current geriatric site framework, though.
Great! Please let me know as soon as you get a response. Be sure to share a link to where Sastreii asserts the tiles are CC0 and indicates which tiles they made.
Sorry, I mean can you link to where these are associated with Sastreii? They were added to the GitHub by pleasingfungus, but we need to have information from the author in order to determine if they are released cc0. In all likelihood, we will need to wait for the next official cc0 release to see what authors granted the new additions for free use.
LPC = Liberated Pixel Cup. An art contest from back in the day. Anything with an "LPC" tag means "this art is made in the Liberated Pixel Cup style and is intended to be compatible with other LPC-tagged artwork" https://lpc.opengameart.org/static/LPC-Style-Guide/build/index.html
It is only tangentially related to the licenses. The original LPC contest artworks were all licensed CC-BY-SA and GPL. Both licenses require all derivatives to be under the same license. The assets above utilized some of the original LPC artowrk (or derivatives of derivatives of the original LPC artwork) therefore, the licenses on the above assets must also be CC-BY-SA and GPL.
@Goddessakura: everything on this site can be used in commercial games, as long as you're adhering to the license terms. Sometimes the license terms mean you have to give credit, sometimes it means you have to share any derivatives you make under the same license, but the terms never mean "can't be used in a commercial game". Let us know if you have any questions about specific licenses.
Adorable.
From your youtube channel to OGA? Yes, definitely.
From OGA to your youtube channel? Depends on where you plan to add it, but probably, yes.
ATMANAN
I don't see any need for special handling of AI assisted artwork submissions as far as "drowning out" other artwork goes. Any user who floods the site with multiple rapid submissions already has their submissions squelched from appearing on the front page temporarily.
If submissions of AI assisted art are "trivial" (anyone could use the AI to make the same thing in just a few minutes) then, again, those submissions are treated the same as other "trivial" submissions. Any time someone draws a crude stick figure of limited usefulness and uploads it, it gets evaluated for how much effort it is saving anyone and will be taken down if it's quicker to make your own than to download that guy's version.
However, keeping it clear which submissions are AI assisted is important, in my opinion. Beyond just tagging something as being AI-generated or AI assisted, there are very specific Terms of Use for the various tools out there. Not all of them are compatible with the open licenses we support. For that reason, I will insist upon any such submission including a link to the specific version of AI tool that was used so that everyone can be confident the allowed usage of output will not get anyone in trouble.
It would be nice to add the checkbox or some additional prompting in the submission process for this. I'm not sure how feasible that is under the current geriatric site framework, though.
Great! Please let me know as soon as you get a response. Be sure to share a link to where Sastreii asserts the tiles are CC0 and indicates which tiles they made.
Sorry, I mean can you link to where these are associated with Sastreii? They were added to the GitHub by pleasingfungus, but we need to have information from the author in order to determine if they are released cc0. In all likelihood, we will need to wait for the next official cc0 release to see what authors granted the new additions for free use.
@maleGuest: Can you provide a link to what you are referring to?
LPC = Liberated Pixel Cup. An art contest from back in the day. Anything with an "LPC" tag means "this art is made in the Liberated Pixel Cup style and is intended to be compatible with other LPC-tagged artwork" https://lpc.opengameart.org/static/LPC-Style-Guide/build/index.html
It is only tangentially related to the licenses. The original LPC contest artworks were all licensed CC-BY-SA and GPL. Both licenses require all derivatives to be under the same license. The assets above utilized some of the original LPC artowrk (or derivatives of derivatives of the original LPC artwork) therefore, the licenses on the above assets must also be CC-BY-SA and GPL.
@Goddessakura: everything on this site can be used in commercial games, as long as you're adhering to the license terms. Sometimes the license terms mean you have to give credit, sometimes it means you have to share any derivatives you make under the same license, but the terms never mean "can't be used in a commercial game". Let us know if you have any questions about specific licenses.
Pages