Well it's about a proprietary AI gone crazy and the evil guy is a corporation resembling Microsoft xD The intro rolls out almost exactly the same and the game is also a raycasting shooter. It's on itch.io as well: https://drummyfish.itch.io/anarch. Anyway just found it curious. The idea with copilot is very clever, I love it.
Yes @MedicineStorm we all greatly appreciate you're always checking this! Personally I'm just worried about the complex legal situation here that's furthermore still without many precedents. For example a badly designed or badly configured AI may very well create something that's very close to a copy paste of something in its dataset which may potentially not be free, it's extremely hard to check with proprietary online AI tools. Also I don't know who the burden of proof of having used the paid version would be on -- if the AI owner decided to sue, would WE have to prove it was made with the paid version or would they have to prove it was NOT made with the paid version? Would this be the same in other countries than the US? Is it even legit for a company to limit the copyright of something merely created with their tool, as if could a hammer manufacturer claim rights to the design of a house I made with their hammer? Also examining the compatibility of proprietary terms of service with free licenses won't be trivial and is risky. I'm just worried about the whole complexity of this and for this reason would like to stick to reusing the good old "hand made" assets whose legal mechanism are well established etc. This is why I would like to have a special AI category or something. Apart from this I think AI is a great tool that can save a lot of time and can be very useful of course.
These look extremely good, I couldn't believe it was made by an AI.
Anyway I'm still personally pretty paranoid about AI generated content, I'm not for banning it here but could we maybe require a special tag for AI? Just for people like me who prefer to avoid AI if possible, purely for fear of legal complications. Maybe in the submission form under "is this your own work" there could be an AI option. There has been a huge boom of these submissions and I think we should maybe have it under a bit of control.
I don't think you have to prove the AI was "influenced", a derivative work is simply a work that "contains major copyrightable elements of an already existing work" (if Wikipedia is to be trusted), i.e. how it was created doesn't play a role, only that it is similar to something already existing. Anyway these backgrounds look pretty generic, I don't think they'd be infringing, also if the terms&conditions are what's claimed then this should prolly be OK.
Indeed this look very awesome, I'm just worried about term&conditions of that AI tool, do they allow things such as commercial use? That's a prerequisite for releasing under CC0. Recently there has been some discussion about AI generated content here, not sure if any concensus has been reached yet.
Indeed very cool, thank you :)
Nice idea and looks very cool, thank you :)
Well it's about a proprietary AI gone crazy and the evil guy is a corporation resembling Microsoft xD The intro rolls out almost exactly the same and the game is also a raycasting shooter. It's on itch.io as well: https://drummyfish.itch.io/anarch. Anyway just found it curious. The idea with copilot is very clever, I love it.
This is pretty cool, I'm loving it, thanks for sharing :)
I have to ask: the intro and the whole game reminds me a lot of one of my own games, have you played it by chance or is it a complete coincidence? xD
OK, very fair points, I'll be still keeping it safe and watching from a distance how this is evolving for now :)
Yes @MedicineStorm we all greatly appreciate you're always checking this! Personally I'm just worried about the complex legal situation here that's furthermore still without many precedents. For example a badly designed or badly configured AI may very well create something that's very close to a copy paste of something in its dataset which may potentially not be free, it's extremely hard to check with proprietary online AI tools. Also I don't know who the burden of proof of having used the paid version would be on -- if the AI owner decided to sue, would WE have to prove it was made with the paid version or would they have to prove it was NOT made with the paid version? Would this be the same in other countries than the US? Is it even legit for a company to limit the copyright of something merely created with their tool, as if could a hammer manufacturer claim rights to the design of a house I made with their hammer? Also examining the compatibility of proprietary terms of service with free licenses won't be trivial and is risky. I'm just worried about the whole complexity of this and for this reason would like to stick to reusing the good old "hand made" assets whose legal mechanism are well established etc. This is why I would like to have a special AI category or something. Apart from this I think AI is a great tool that can save a lot of time and can be very useful of course.
These look extremely good, I couldn't believe it was made by an AI.
Anyway I'm still personally pretty paranoid about AI generated content, I'm not for banning it here but could we maybe require a special tag for AI? Just for people like me who prefer to avoid AI if possible, purely for fear of legal complications. Maybe in the submission form under "is this your own work" there could be an AI option. There has been a huge boom of these submissions and I think we should maybe have it under a bit of control.
I don't think you have to prove the AI was "influenced", a derivative work is simply a work that "contains major copyrightable elements of an already existing work" (if Wikipedia is to be trusted), i.e. how it was created doesn't play a role, only that it is similar to something already existing. Anyway these backgrounds look pretty generic, I don't think they'd be infringing, also if the terms&conditions are what's claimed then this should prolly be OK.
Indeed this look very awesome, I'm just worried about term&conditions of that AI tool, do they allow things such as commercial use? That's a prerequisite for releasing under CC0. Recently there has been some discussion about AI generated content here, not sure if any concensus has been reached yet.
Commander LMAO that's an epic post, reminds me of how they used to make sprites for Doom weapons.
Pages