The specific license isn't the issue. As I said, the conditions in your attribution instructions are incompatible with ALL the licenses on OGA. What needs to change is the conditions forbidding redistribution and resale.
Jaidyn is correct. Redistribution and resale are neccessary features of free/ibre licenses. Forbidding them is incompatible with all the licenses on OGA, and renders the assets effectively unusable from a legal standpoint.
@Mushra Games; would you be willing to omit that restriction? Until then I must mark this submission as having a licensing issue in order to prevent people from using it in a way you may not approve of.
I recommend OGA-BY. It requires people to credit you and link back here wherever they use it. Pretty hard for someone to claim it's theirs when they are linking back here and saying "Saa_Matt made this". Let me know if you have any questions about licenses. We're happy to help.
There should be no hashmarks in the tags. It makes them unsearchable. They are not related to twitter tags. Additionally, tags like "Game" and "music" are kind of pointless. Everything on the site is for games, and this asset is already categorized as music.
Party_lollipop and Lolipop_chiptune seem like they go well together. Why not have them as one submission with two songs?
The attribution notice you have: "...just don't change the document and obviously don't register it as yours..." What document? The file type? Please know that CC0 allows people to change the song in any way they wish, including the removal or alteration of metadata. That condition is essentially unenforcable. Would you be willing to alter or remove that part to avoid confusion? Until then, I have to disable downloads to prevent people from using this file in a way you may not approve of. The same applies to https://opengameart.org/content/lollipop-chiptune
Ouch! So you definitely are familiar with this pain. I would like to say "come help! We need your skills", but I doubt you want to do more of your day job as hobby volunteer work. Death's Darling (aka ElizaWy) is making some pretty big strides on a replacement OGA framework (PHP, but not Drupal), so if you are interested, we'll meet up and talk about next steps. No pressure though.
Per the submission guidelines, you are also required to provide a link to firefly's TOS page.Last I heard, firefly's TOS also included a "not for commercial use" clause. Has that changed?EDIT: Fixed, thanks! :)
Great!
Now the only issue is the "no distribution/no resale" restriction that's conflicts with the license.EDIT: Fixed, thanks! :)
The specific license isn't the issue. As I said, the conditions in your attribution instructions are incompatible with ALL the licenses on OGA. What needs to change is the conditions forbidding redistribution and resale.EDIT: Fixed, thanks! :)
Jaidyn is correct. Redistribution and resale are neccessary features of free/ibre licenses. Forbidding them is incompatible with all the licenses on OGA, and renders the assets effectively unusable from a legal standpoint.@Mushra Games; would you be willing to omit that restriction? Until then I must mark this submission as having a licensing issue in order to prevent people from using it in a way you may not approve of.EDIT: Fixed, thanks! :)
Any time. Sounds good! Thanks.
I recommend OGA-BY. It requires people to credit you and link back here wherever they use it. Pretty hard for someone to claim it's theirs when they are linking back here and saying "Saa_Matt made this". Let me know if you have any questions about licenses. We're happy to help.
"Mutagen Dusk"
Nice tune. I like it.
A few issues, though:There should be no hashmarks in the tags. It makes them unsearchable. They are not related to twitter tags. Additionally, tags like "Game" and "music" are kind of pointless. Everything on the site is for games, and this asset is already categorized as music.The attribution notice you have: "...just don't change the document and obviously don't register it as yours..." What document? The file type? Please know that CC0 allows people to change the song in any way they wish, including the removal or alteration of metadata. That condition is essentially unenforcable. Would you be willing to alter or remove that part to avoid confusion? Until then, I have to disable downloads to prevent people from using this file in a way you may not approve of. The same applies to https://opengameart.org/content/lollipop-chiptuneEDIT: Fixed, thanks! :)
Bumped for new content.
Ouch! So you definitely are familiar with this pain. I would like to say "come help! We need your skills", but I doubt you want to do more of your day job as hobby volunteer work. Death's Darling (aka ElizaWy) is making some pretty big strides on a replacement OGA framework (PHP, but not Drupal), so if you are interested, we'll meet up and talk about next steps. No pressure though.
Pages