This looks great! thanks for sharing. However, the "don't resell" restriction makes it so no one can use this in a game, even if the game is free. I get that you mean don't resell it by itself, but it still creates a legal entanglement for everyone else as well. Even if someone were to sell it, they would be required to link to this page where it's free, so I'm not sure how they would effectively make any money on it anyway. Would you be willing to forego that restriction. Untill then I have to lock all downloads for it. I can provide more information if you would like. Let me know if you have questions.
This character looks like it has some potential. It may be pretty difficult for others to use as is, though. Any chance of a "fleshed out" version, or layer separation?
I really do think your work is good. But do not sacrifice your well-being to do something you don't enjoy. If you are still deriving satisfaction from making this music, then by all means keep going. You do not owe others your talents if making this music is draining you.
One only feels the limits of skills when one pushes up against those limits, stretching and expanding them. You are already beyond the point where your limits used to be when you started. :)
@Tom Peter: I believe the confusion stems from the fact you have indicated above this is NOT your work. In which case, you don't have the authority to say who can use the track and you are not the person people should be giving credit for its use.
It's your call, but it tends to make the assets a lot easier to find. If you do choose to edit the original, add this expansion, and request deletion of this one, I'll be sure to bump the original to the front as if it were a new submission. That will allow people to see the new features you've added.
You're not missing anything, I understood that part about the author field. It is a known bug. Until it is fixed, the best way to attribute the author is as I stated above. Specifically:
"I'm not sure how to specify an author so to be clear I didn't make the actual assets"
The author can be specified in the "Copyright/Attribution Notice" section. See https://opengameart.org/content/faq#q-how-to-credit for an example of the preferred way to give attribution in this situation. However, CC0 doesn't require attribution, so this is not required in this case. I still recommend doing so, but it's your decision.
This looks great! thanks for sharing.
However, the "don't resell" restriction makes it so no one can use this in a game, even if the game is free. I get that you mean don't resell it by itself, but it still creates a legal entanglement for everyone else as well. Even if someone were to sell it, they would be required to link to this page where it's free, so I'm not sure how they would effectively make any money on it anyway. Would you be willing to forego that restriction. Untill then I have to lock all downloads for it.I can provide more information if you would like. Let me know if you have questions.EDIT: Fixed, thanks! :)
Hey! glad you're back.
This character looks like it has some potential. It may be pretty difficult for others to use as is, though. Any chance of a "fleshed out" version, or layer separation?
I really do think your work is good. But do not sacrifice your well-being to do something you don't enjoy. If you are still deriving satisfaction from making this music, then by all means keep going. You do not owe others your talents if making this music is draining you.
One only feels the limits of skills when one pushes up against those limits, stretching and expanding them. You are already beyond the point where your limits used to be when you started. :)
@Tom Peter: I believe the confusion stems from the fact you have indicated above this is NOT your work. In which case, you don't have the authority to say who can use the track and you are not the person people should be giving credit for its use.EDIT: Fixed, thanks! :)
It's your call, but it tends to make the assets a lot easier to find. If you do choose to edit the original, add this expansion, and request deletion of this one, I'll be sure to bump the original to the front as if it were a new submission. That will allow people to see the new features you've added.
This seems better included with the assets it is expanding upon. Why not add this to the original Symphony players submission?
You're not missing anything, I understood that part about the author field. It is a known bug. Until it is fixed, the best way to attribute the author is as I stated above. Specifically:
The author can be specified in the "Copyright/Attribution Notice" section. See https://opengameart.org/content/faq#q-how-to-credit for an example of the preferred way to give attribution in this situation. However, CC0 doesn't require attribution, so this is not required in this case. I still recommend doing so, but it's your decision.
Dim required CC-BY, not CC-BY-SA. Is that intentional?EDIT: Fixed, thanks!
Pages