unless everything I've ever drawn is also a theft from every artist whose work that I have ever seen with my eyes.
This conflates inspiration with derivation. These are not the same thing. The difference between the two is the heart of the AI art debate. Regardless, kooow was aware of the temporary AI policy already, having self-submitted this page to AI assisted artwork collection before the first comment was made here. :)
The "except selling it" stipulation conflicts with the license, which does not allow any additional restrictions. Would you be willing to omit that verbiage? Until then I must mark this as having a licensing issue.
@GreenAlien: I don't know of any new aliens Kenney is working on right now. The following two submissions have pretty much all of Kenney's aliens to date:
Thanks @Lordomi. It could be a false-positive, but that's no reason to throw caution to the wind. @thesoupbird: Any light you can shed on the apparent trojan inside main.exe of your game?
EDIT: No response. Potentially harmful link removed.
the license link in the help file - LudicArts.txt inside the .zip conflicts with CC-BY 4.0. It is fine to have your own proprietary license for content distributed from your website, but the content shared on OGA must be under the terms of the licenses accepted on OGA. Would you be willing to omit the license link from this package. Until then I must mark this as having a licensing issue to prevent usage you may not approve of. Let me know if you have any questions.
I have encountered some of that, but I may have had better luck shutting their lies down since the reason I rejected their art was not because it was AI art. It was because it didn't meet my commission criteria. In my case, I didn't care if it was AI or not so long as it created a stable animation loop that transitioned smoothly and realistically. The artwork they tried to give me and say "I finished the commission. pay up." looked like crap when it was animated. So I said, "no, you didn't finish. My requirements clearly say xyz and this doesn't meet that."
My point being, be sure to define your requirements in a way that excludes the garbage artifacts that often show up in AI art. Specifying "no AI art" might help a little, though I think you'll get more of the 'this is a witch hunt' responses for that. It isn't actually very specific. It's like saying "no blockchain!" but there are multiple forms of blockchain tech, many of which have nothing to do with the typical notorious "Steal art, mint NFT, sell it without artist's permission, argue the theft is actually beneficial to artist when caught" tactic.
This conflates inspiration with derivation. These are not the same thing. The difference between the two is the heart of the AI art debate. Regardless, kooow was aware of the temporary AI policy already, having self-submitted this page to AI assisted artwork collection before the first comment was made here. :)
Great!
The license.txt within this .zip file still shows the extra restriction, though.EDIT: Fixed, thanks! :)
The same situation on the following submissions as well, due to the restriction in the LICENSE.txt file.https://opengameart.org/content/halloween-pixel-art-tileset-top-downhttps://opengameart.org/content/basic-tiles-for-gbstudiogame-boyhttps://opengameart.org/content/small-city-tilesets-8px-size-pixelarthttps://opengameart.org/content/laboratory-tileset-pixelart-16pxEDIT: Fixed, thanks! :)
The "except selling it" stipulation conflicts with the license, which does not allow any additional restrictions. Would you be willing to omit that verbiage? Until then I must mark this as having a licensing issue.EDIT: Fixed, thanks! :)
@GreenAlien: I don't know of any new aliens Kenney is working on right now. The following two submissions have pretty much all of Kenney's aliens to date:
Is this 2D art or Document? I honestly don't know.
What does it being a toddler game have to do with linking to the game?
Thanks @Lordomi. It could be a false-positive, but that's no reason to throw caution to the wind. @thesoupbird: Any light you can shed on the apparent trojan inside main.exe of your game?
EDIT: No response. Potentially harmful link removed.
the license link in the help file - LudicArts.txt inside the .zip conflicts with CC-BY 4.0. It is fine to have your own proprietary license for content distributed from your website, but the content shared on OGA must be under the terms of the licenses accepted on OGA. Would you be willing to omit the license link from this package. Until then I must mark this as having a licensing issue to prevent usage you may not approve of. Let me know if you have any questions.EDIT: Fixed, thanks! :)
Agreed.
I have encountered some of that, but I may have had better luck shutting their lies down since the reason I rejected their art was not because it was AI art. It was because it didn't meet my commission criteria. In my case, I didn't care if it was AI or not so long as it created a stable animation loop that transitioned smoothly and realistically. The artwork they tried to give me and say "I finished the commission. pay up." looked like crap when it was animated. So I said, "no, you didn't finish. My requirements clearly say xyz and this doesn't meet that."
My point being, be sure to define your requirements in a way that excludes the garbage artifacts that often show up in AI art. Specifying "no AI art" might help a little, though I think you'll get more of the 'this is a witch hunt' responses for that. It isn't actually very specific. It's like saying "no blockchain!" but there are multiple forms of blockchain tech, many of which have nothing to do with the typical notorious "Steal art, mint NFT, sell it without artist's permission, argue the theft is actually beneficial to artist when caught" tactic.
Pages