@JaidynReiman: Good. Thanks for tracking all that down. That would suggest this: https://opengameart.org/content/lpc-teen-unisex-base-clothes is not outdated. The licensing is correct on that page, but only because it includes content from Joe White, who's derivatives remain CC-BY-SA/GPL. (When there is a pack of assets with various licenses for various subcomponents of the pack, only the most restrictive common license to the entire pack is used as the whole pack's license. Most of the content on that pack is CC-BY-SA, GPL, and OGA-BY, but because Joe White's pants are only CC-BY-SA, and GPL, the "whole pack's license" becomes CC-BY-SA and GPL sans OGA-BY.)
I beleive Death's Darling did update her older entries on OGA to include OGA-BY, but only the ones where all content within the pack was covered by OGA-BY. It is also why this https://opengameart.org/content/liberated-pixel-cup-lpc-base-assets-spri... lists CC-BY-SA and GPL in the sidebar, but has the OGA-BY caveat you mentioned; A lot of the content in that pack is under OGA-BY, but not all of it. If there are any other LPC submissions where it should also include OGA-BY, let me (or Death's Darling) know, because we definitely want that extra freedom on those assets.
"...I can't find any indication that the "original" Long-Sleeve Shirt was not also a derivative of Joe White..." (Conclusion: It isn't a derivative of Joe White's work)
Although Death's Darling's pack that Nyom derived this asset from is not OGA-BY, all the subcomponents used to create this, are.
@Nyom: If you are willing to include it, we would love to have OGA-BY 3.0 listed as one of the licenses for these assets here. :)
ElizaWy's Shortsleeve Shirt is actually dual released under OGA-BY 3.0, CC-BY-SA 3.0, and GPL 3.0
Where is the Shortsleeve shirt released under OGA-BY 3.0? Is the longsleeve shirt based on the shortsleeve shirt? or is Death's Darling's longsleeve based on something else unrelated? Speculating on how it was created is secondary to how Death's Darling herself attributed the derivatives she created.
I'm actually not sure where Joe White comes into play here.
Nor am I. It looks like Joe White created the pants but had no contribution to the shirt. Death's Darling didn't link to any of the other assets she derived hers from, so it's difficult to trace the provenance.
I think the original shirt was by RedShrike. Joe White may have done some modifications later down the line, but for some reason wasn't credited by bluecarrot on the Shortsleeve shirt despite being credited elsewhere.
My guess is Joe White may have made later modifications (to a shirt?) but it was not upstream of bluecarrot's modifications, so was correctly not credited in bluecarrot's modifications. Again, difficult to tell without having links to the specific assets you're referring to.
I question crediting the artist of the base model for adding assets onto the model... IDK if that counts as a derivative or not
Creating assets specifically so a certain base model can "wear" them does not make them derivative of the base model... UNLESS the base model was integral to the creation process of the clothing assets, which is likely the case. If you can make the clothing without referencing or tracing or copying parts from, or materially using the proportion of the base model, then no they aren't derivatives. Is this a shirt derived from flesh? I don't know, but it would explain why Redshrike, as the base model creator, is being credited for derivative clothing. This also applies if the female model was a derivative of the male model, and the shirt was subsequently a derivative of the female model.
the Longsleeve Female shirt by ElizaWy does not appear to be a derivative of the Longsleeve Male Shirt.
Death's Darling indicates the shirt is based on Redshrike's female LPC model: https://opengameart.org/content/lpc-teen-unisex-base-clothes which is CC-BY-SA 3.0 and GPL 3.0. It's possible Redshrike changed his license to include OGA-BY after Death's Darling made her derivative, which makes Death's Darling's derivative eligible for OGA-BY, which makes this derivative eligible for OGA-BY as well... but the change has to cascade down from the top first.
I'm also not clear on where Wulax fits in here. Did he make a longsleeve shirt? is it the SAME longsleeve shirt that bluecarrot derived his from? Or did bluecarrot make a separate longsleeve shirt using none of Wulax's shirt and only basing it on Redshrike's base?
TL;DR: Please provide links to the specific assets being referenced. Without that, we can't change anything unless we hear directly from Bluecarrot, Redshrike, and Death's Darling (We can certainly ask them, but I'd like to be sure this isn't a question they already answered via attribution.)
Is it possible you have a cached CREDITS.TXT file on your device? Or you've downloaded the file back when there was only one item in the collection and now your device isn't overwriting the old version with the new one?
THIS FILE IS FOR INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY. NO WARRANTY OF ANY KIND IS EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE, AND NONINFRINGEMENT. IN NO EVENT SHALL OPENGAMEART.ORG BE LIABLE FOR ANY CLAIM, DAMAGES, OR OTHER LIABILITY, WHETHER IN AN ACTION OF CONTRACT, TORT, OR OTHERWISE, ARISING FROM, OUT OF, OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE USE OF THIS FILE OR THE INFORMATION IN IT.
In plain English: This credits file is automatically generated to the best of our ability, but it remains YOUR RESPONSIBILITY as a game developer to ensure that the art you use is attributed properly. That is, we can't be held liable even if all of the information in this file is completely wrong. In addition, some of the art listed in this file may have SPECIAL ATTRIBUTION INSTRUCTIONS that ask that you credit the artist in a particular way, rather than a verbatim copyright notice. In those cases, you will probably need to hand-edit this file to comply with their instructions. In some older art, attribution instructions may be included in the art description itself. Please check the art page to be sure.
We recommend that you delete this notice when you're sure the information here is correct and the attribution instructions are properly followed. If you aren't the game developer and you're seeing this notice here in the credits, it probably means that the developer hasn't properly verified the attribution information contained herein even though it said they were supposed to do it right on the page where they downloaded this file.
Good find. I'm looking into it now for potential upload. Looks like some reorganization should happen first since it's laid out for game-specific compilation, not game-agnostic general assets. Lots of stuff, though. Lots of quality stuff!
bumped for new content
I am not able to replicate this issue.
@JaidynReiman: Good. Thanks for tracking all that down. That would suggest this: https://opengameart.org/content/lpc-teen-unisex-base-clothes is not outdated. The licensing is correct on that page, but only because it includes content from Joe White, who's derivatives remain CC-BY-SA/GPL. (When there is a pack of assets with various licenses for various subcomponents of the pack, only the most restrictive common license to the entire pack is used as the whole pack's license. Most of the content on that pack is CC-BY-SA, GPL, and OGA-BY, but because Joe White's pants are only CC-BY-SA, and GPL, the "whole pack's license" becomes CC-BY-SA and GPL sans
OGA-BY.)I beleive Death's Darling did update her older entries on OGA to include OGA-BY, but only the ones where all content within the pack was covered by OGA-BY. It is also why this https://opengameart.org/content/liberated-pixel-cup-lpc-base-assets-spri... lists CC-BY-SA and GPL in the sidebar, but has the OGA-BY caveat you mentioned; A lot of the content in that pack is under OGA-BY, but not all of it. If there are any other LPC submissions where it should also include OGA-BY, let me (or Death's Darling) know, because we definitely want that extra freedom on those assets.
The good news is, that also addressed this uncertainty of mine:
Although Death's Darling's pack that Nyom derived this asset from is not OGA-BY, all the subcomponents used to create this, are.
@Nyom: If you are willing to include it, we would love to have OGA-BY 3.0 listed as one of the licenses for these assets here. :)
Where is the Shortsleeve shirt released under OGA-BY 3.0? Is the longsleeve shirt based on the shortsleeve shirt? or is Death's Darling's longsleeve based on something else unrelated? Speculating on how it was created is secondary to how Death's Darling herself attributed the derivatives she created.
Nor am I. It looks like Joe White created the pants but had no contribution to the shirt. Death's Darling didn't link to any of the other assets she derived hers from, so it's difficult to trace the provenance.
My guess is Joe White may have made later modifications (to a shirt?) but it was not upstream of bluecarrot's modifications, so was correctly not credited in bluecarrot's modifications. Again, difficult to tell without having links to the specific assets you're referring to.
Creating assets specifically so a certain base model can "wear" them does not make them derivative of the base model... UNLESS the base model was integral to the creation process of the clothing assets, which is likely the case. If you can make the clothing without referencing or tracing or copying parts from, or materially using the proportion of the base model, then no they aren't derivatives. Is this a shirt derived from flesh? I don't know, but it would explain why Redshrike, as the base model creator, is being credited for derivative clothing. This also applies if the female model was a derivative of the male model, and the shirt was subsequently a derivative of the female model.
Death's Darling indicates the shirt is based on Redshrike's female LPC model: https://opengameart.org/content/lpc-teen-unisex-base-clothes which is CC-BY-SA 3.0 and GPL 3.0. It's possible Redshrike changed his license to include OGA-BY after Death's Darling made her derivative, which makes Death's Darling's derivative eligible for OGA-BY, which makes this derivative eligible for OGA-BY as well... but the change has to cascade down from the top first.
I'm also not clear on where Wulax fits in here. Did he make a longsleeve shirt? is it the SAME longsleeve shirt that bluecarrot derived his from? Or did bluecarrot make a separate longsleeve shirt using none of Wulax's shirt and only basing it on Redshrike's base?
TL;DR: Please provide links to the specific assets being referenced. Without that, we can't change anything unless we hear directly from Bluecarrot, Redshrike, and Death's Darling (We can certainly ask them, but I'd like to be sure this isn't a question they already answered via attribution.)
Is it possible you have a cached CREDITS.TXT file on your device? Or you've downloaded the file back when there was only one item in the collection and now your device isn't overwriting the old version with the new one?
When I download the credits file from your collection, it contains all 8 entries:
###############################################
OpenGameArt.org automatically generated credits file notice:
THIS FILE IS FOR INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY. NO WARRANTY OF ANY KIND IS EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE, AND NONINFRINGEMENT. IN NO EVENT SHALL OPENGAMEART.ORG BE LIABLE FOR ANY CLAIM, DAMAGES, OR OTHER LIABILITY, WHETHER IN AN ACTION OF CONTRACT, TORT, OR OTHERWISE, ARISING FROM, OUT OF, OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE USE OF THIS FILE OR THE INFORMATION IN IT.
In plain English: This credits file is automatically generated to the best of our ability, but it remains YOUR RESPONSIBILITY as a game developer to ensure that the art you use is attributed properly. That is, we can't be held liable even if all of the information in this file is completely wrong. In addition, some of the art listed in this file may have SPECIAL ATTRIBUTION INSTRUCTIONS that ask that you credit the artist in a particular way, rather than a verbatim copyright notice. In those cases, you will probably need to hand-edit this file to comply with their instructions. In some older art, attribution instructions may be included in the art description itself. Please check the art page to be sure.
We recommend that you delete this notice when you're sure the information here is correct and the attribution instructions are properly followed. If you aren't the game developer and you're seeing this notice here in the credits, it probably means that the developer hasn't properly verified the attribution information contained herein even though it said they were supposed to do it right on the page where they downloaded this file.
###############################################
Title:
Mobile UI Buttons, Arrows and Shoot
Author:
Robin Lamb
URL:
https://opengameart.org/content/mobile-ui-buttons-arrows-and-shoot
License(s):
* CC0 ( http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/legalcode )
Copyright/Attribution Notice:
Robin Lamb
File(s):
* mobile_buttons_png.zip
* mobile_buttons_svg.zip
----------------------------------------
Title:
Coin animation
Author:
Flixberry Entertainment
URL:
https://opengameart.org/content/coin-animation
License(s):
* CC-BY 4.0 ( https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode )
* CC-BY 3.0 ( http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/legalcode )
Copyright/Attribution Notice:
no need to credit, if you like credit Flixberry Entertainment
File(s):
* star coin animation Pack.zip
----------------------------------------
Title:
Bomb sprite
Author:
Znevs
URL:
https://opengameart.org/content/bomb-sprite
License(s):
* CC0 ( http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/legalcode )
File(s):
* bomb_anim.png
----------------------------------------
Title:
Pixel Explosion (12 Frames)
Author:
JROB774
URL:
https://opengameart.org/content/pixel-explosion-12-frames
License(s):
* CC-BY 3.0 ( http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/legalcode )
File(s):
* Explosion.png
----------------------------------------
Title:
Muffled Distant Explosion
Author:
NenadSimic
URL:
https://opengameart.org/content/muffled-distant-explosion
License(s):
* CC0 ( http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/legalcode )
File(s):
* NenadSimic - Muffled Distant Explosion.wav
----------------------------------------
Title:
Synthesized explosion
Author:
Iwan Gabovitch
URL:
https://opengameart.org/content/synthesized-explosion
License(s):
* CC0 ( http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/legalcode )
File(s):
* synthetic_explosion_1.flac
----------------------------------------
Title:
Simple Fuse Sound
Author:
themightyglider
URL:
https://opengameart.org/content/simple-fuse-sound
License(s):
* CC0 ( http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/legalcode )
File(s):
* fuse.ogg
----------------------------------------
Title:
Level up, power up, Coin get (13 Sounds)
Author:
wobbleboxx
URL:
https://opengameart.org/content/level-up-power-up-coin-get-13-sounds
License(s):
* CC0 ( http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/legalcode )
Copyright/Attribution Notice:
This pack is released under the public domain CC0 li
cense.
If you want to give credit (not required): "wobbleboxx.com"
File(s):
* SoundPack01.zip
----------------------------------------
They aren't supported because they are software specific. Would you be able to convert them to .midi, .flac, or .wav?
Good find. I'm looking into it now for potential upload. Looks like some reorganization should happen first since it's laid out for game-specific compilation, not game-agnostic general assets. Lots of stuff, though. Lots of quality stuff!
Wonderful! The side frames in that demo image look really good to me.
Any thought given to chitinous wings? Then you'd have the wing trifecta
Bumped for new content.
Pages