Which one of these four songs sounds the best?
Saturday, February 24, 2018 - 12:59
These are just versions of my boss theme "Minor Boss R"- the first one is just a dry dump from the chips so to speak, without effects of any kind - how it would have been on a retro console back in the day.
With the second one I was playing around with reverb, eq, compression, excitement, etc, but I'm not sure which of these two versions actually sounds better. I think the second version is a bit too resonant due to the reverb, which may have been overdone. On the other hand the first version sounds a bit flat.
EDIT: There are 4 versions now.
What do you guys think?
Attachments:
Honestly "minor boss-r ver diff" and "minor boss-r ver 3" sound like 2 form boss music where "ver diff" fades into "ver 3" when the boss your fighting transforms into its second form.
I really like all of "minor boss-r ver diff" and "minor boss-r ver 3"
but if youre looking for a straight answer then "minor boss-r ver diff" would probably be best for a minor boss battle
I see. Interesting way of looking at it. I also prefer one of those against the original. Which one, I'm not too sure cx
Thanks for the feedback! It sounds corny but you're actually being very helpful XD
A 4th version was added which isn't a chiptune. I think I made the drums too loud on that one :P
It sounds really awesome. I have no problems with the drums volume.
Off topic a bit but do you do commissions or artwork trades for music?
Thanks, glad ya like it!
And yeah, I actually do do both those things ^^
I have to say I like minor boss-r ver diff.ogg the best. The first one sounded kinda incomplete and I just didn't like the other ones as much. They are all pretty good though, none of them are awful.
If you ever want to do an art trade, 3D models, still 2D scenes, 3D scenes, or pixel art sprites, or pixel art scenes. Let me know, Id love to have at least one of your songs in my JRPG!
Ah yes! I would need a cover art picture for Corrosive Caverns at some point anyway, so if you can do that, I'd love to trade with ya ^^
@Jastiv Fair point. I prefer the 4th version, but for a chiptune the second one is probably the best ^^ - thanks for your feedback!
If you have an idea for that coverart send it my way over PM else, Ive got an idea in mind for it.
I'm more interested in seeing yours tbh!