abstract-rts-pack
An Abstract set of graphics generated with Adobe's Firefly, and the "1-bit-pack" original art-work pack by Kenney.
These images have been generated using the Firefly tool, and using the image below as reference:
https://opengameart.org/content/1-bit-pack:Tilesheet/colored.png
(so you can also add Kenney in the credits, even if the original image is licensed CC0)
cde4112c71998afa507f93beda36d61c 1bitpack_kenney_1.1.zip
c9c73c5a9271b639e552d006dcde3b3e Tilesheet/colored.png
The terms of use of "Firefly" request that "Firefly" appears in the Credits, so attribution should also be given to "Firefly".
The license from the original work has been changed from CC0 to CC-by-sa in order to garanty that Firefly is credited as requested by its term of use.
Version of Firefly used: "March-2024"
Terms of use of Adobe's Firefly: https://www.adobe.com/legal/licenses-terms/adobe-gen-ai-user-guidelines....
Comments
This was MedicineStorm's concern in the other submission:
So commercial use is supported conditionally.
Hi JaidynReiman, as discussed with MedicineStorm, the commercial use restriction doesn't seem to apply on this version of Firefly.
Correct. That restriction is only for beta Firefly, which is not the version used on these.
I dunno, I'm still pretty unsure about allowing generative AI 'art' on OGA. It kind of defeats the purpose IMHO.
The defeat already started 30 years ago. My mom worked all her career in the same administration. She said between the beginning and the end of her career, they were doing exactly the same job with only half of people, because of computers. When my parents were 18 years old, everyone was able to find a job. Today, for one job offer in my country, there are 18 unemployed person. I agree, there is a kind of defeat the way some people are left on the side due to the use of computers.
huh?
hold up
what purpose of oga is this defeating
I think the argument is that OpenGameArt is about art and allowing "AI art" defeats the purpose of it because "AI art" is not real art or something?
OGA is for the purpose of providing open assets for game development that anyone can use. I don't see how allowing for AI art negates that, especially since the AI art is marked as AI art to begin with. If you don't want to use AI art, then don't use AI art. There's plenty of art on this website that's not AI art. And the team on the website are being restrictive on how much is allowed at a time to not flood the latest entries with nothing but AI generated stuff.
The main reason I'm not using AI generation is because the stuff I have seen through AI art generation just doesn't look good enough. Its good enough for concept art but not for actual real usage.
I would like to point out that we have not allowed AI art on OGA. There have been 60 AI art submissions on OGA so far. Of those, we have (tentatively) allowed two.*
Assets with quesitonable legal origins are not allowed, including AI submissions from technology who's training data may be considered unethically obtained.
Assets that are, in essence, functionally unusable in a game or trivial to produce are not allowed, including AI submissions that have had little or no human artistic input, curation, or refinement.
*With that being said, there seems to be entirely too much uncertainty and instability about AI art as an art medium. At least for now. Not because we fear new things that are hard to understand, but because AI art itself is uncertain what role it should be playing.
If anyone has thoughts about what role AI art should have here on OGA, even if that role is "exile" in your opinion, share your thoughts here (on the separate AIAA thread). Please include your reasoning. Why do you feel that way? What purpose does OGA have in your view, and how does AI art defeat or support that purpose in your opinion?
Yeah for me personally I experimented with AI art mostly to get some rough concepts down. Nothing I saw actually looked usable in any project, game or otherwise.
Thanks for providing that update, I'm sure others who have major concerns like that will find it appreciated.