I removed a few sounds on my freesound military sfx pack after a comment - probably by leilei (undesired) - claimed they were protected. (this was probably in 2012) I had to agree that they sounded a bit too good to be self made by us military and remembered that the video from which they were taken seemed very edited sound-wise, when I ripped them from us military video material back in 2009, naively thinking "they probably made sure they have the rights to publish the result as public domain material".
It would be really helpful if the filename was pointed out (I assumed you mean the ExplosionMetal*wav files) and if there was a way to prove that the sound actually was originally from a sound library (not easy if the libraries aren't online available legally in the case of soundideas of course). If you could have been able to point out the exact soundideas sound pack, it would have been helpful.
So I couldn't confirm that the sound was taken from a protected library but figured better safe than sorry and that leilei is more experienced at tracking down protected game assets, so now this submission contains a different explosion, which is taken from a military video recording, which did not make the impression of being edited - http://www.freesound.org/people/qubodup/sounds/67474/
Very cool! If this was made made in LMMS: some OGA musicians actually upload the project files (inside zips usually).
swlu, thanks for releasing and sharing the tracks under cc-by3!
andrelopes1993 freesound.org has the sounds you're asking for. Remember to give attribution to the authors! :)
Pretty cool stuff! I added a complete preview.
Cool! How was this made?
There appears to be some controversy around the copyright status of this music:
I wonder if STK team is aware.
"Would it be possible to just tolerate the use in iOS software as long as the terms of CC-BY-SA are followed?"
There is a little bit of information in the CC FAQ on this: #Can_I_change_the_license_terms_or_conditions
Okay, I unflagged the submission since you confirm that authorship and licensing is now clarified. Note that the archive apparently is double-gzip-ed (aunpack CLI tool failes to un pack it. I have to gzip -d twice before I get a tar).
My understanding is that we're waiting for AT to reply. If that's not correct and the submission is ready to be published again, please let us know.
Thanks for the patience!
Thanks for the submission. I find some information confusing.
As part of the OGA moderation team I disabled downloading until licensing/authorship is clear
There are files that you created and files that you did not create?
Are there files that are remixes of files by others?
I would assume the screenshot contains art by many people but licensing and authorship needs to be clear for all files in a submission, as well as previews.
the licensing choice is not for stating "there are files under A but also files under B license" but for stating "all files are dual-licensed under A and B licenses".
I recommend replacing this submission with a zip and preview that contains only CC0 works only made by you (yd) and uploading the pack to the AT forums.